2:00pmET Introduction – Begin recording– Steve Gilbert
 MEMORIES: What, if anything, do you remember about the the last time you took a math course or learned math in some organized way?
Dav;idP: Grad calc for teachers…. why didn’t undergrads get taught this way? Emphasized usages…. did fine in calcI, struggled in calcII, promised teacher NOT to take calcIII (majored in comp. sci)…”relationship bet student and teacher is paramount…. so is being wiling to try alternatives”
DaleP: YES – relationship bet student/teacher& using variety of teaching techniques; “all math teachers are not good math teachers” “every math teacher is not a good math teacher” just becuase you know/understand math doesn’t mean you can teach math; Ellington “there’s good music, and there’s the other kind” – similar for math; similar for science….
People who really know the subject very well does NOT mean that you can (or cannot) teach someone else…
DaleP: Last learning math experince… [fun, interesting helps TEACH math]; Uses a form to get students to describe an intersting math fact.
[NOTE: TEACHING AND LEARNING AT SAME TIME IS POSSIBLE, HIGHLY DESIRABLE…. EVERYBODY LEARNING FROM EVERYBODY… ADULT EDUCATION (ONLY)?]
JJ: ABOUT TO “RETIRE” – has taught at high school, comm. college; math WAS taught differently… remembers taking 3 basiclevel math courses by Navy via “correspondence” courses; was curioius about HOW navy was teaching; took grad engineering course approx 10 years ago; online geometry course via VaTech — all pleasant… he was approaching learning math differently from most his students…. he is willing to be persistent, can accept arcane methods,…, agrees with variety of ways of presenting, now teaches lib arts students (age 2045 – some younger, some older) who don’t have to take much math…. most arrive with fear of math, bad experiences, would prefer NOT to be in this math class; when asks students to introduce themselves… MANY say they have had bad experiences, have low expectations of themselves, hate math,
Asst principla wrote goal for JJ teaching to have >60% score/be above “average”!!!
JJ .. we have students arriving in comm college not knowing how to add fractions, multiply…. [instituitons now getting rid of developmental courses]
DaleP: 80% of here math 101 entering students have fear, anxiety re math!
DaleP: 30% of teaching math to these students is about personal stuff, “math can be fun”
JJ: “Math is fun” on his business cards…. ” but sometimes it’s hard fun”
JJ: sees students postpoining math requirements till very last possible term to meet grad requirements
SWG: I believe most people are not born hating math.
trying to
Beth: not a math teacher; had prereqs to become dental hygienist
Anxiety based on low selfexpectations of learning math
took chem in high school; many friends took physics; then at community college when took organic chem did better than peers; who had not taken high school chem;
“GET THRU” the course
Students today more “niche oriented” job/career focused; taking courses for those reasons.
Sally: how enable/guide/help students to be able to take initiative in seeking/finding help when having trouble learning something in particular…
DaleP: What is it that you are GOOD at? How long did it take you to learn how to do that well???? Similar to math…
 TRIGGERS: What retriggers your reactions to that experience? Positive? Negative?
Know anyone suffering from PMTSD (PostMathTraumaStressSyndrome)?
WHY DO (HOW MANY) PEOPLE FROM OTHER COUNTRIES DO NOT HAVE SAME PREPONDERANCE OF MATH ANXIETY, MATH PHOBIA, ETC…????
 USAGE: How, if at all, has the most advanced math you ever learned been useful later on? How often?
 ADVICE: Resources, strategies, etc. for those about to begin teaching “Math 101”? For those trying to “get thru Math 101”?
 BANE OR BOON? What % of adults have been prevented or delayed by Math 101 from achieving goals important to them? What % of adults has Math 101 helped to identify and achieve goals important to them?
*[Note: In this context, “Math 101” includes undergraduate courses with that label AND similar courses and activities, related prerequisites, college developmental/remedial courses, independent learning, etc. Most include some overlap with “beginning algebra”. ]
Why “Killer” Gateway Courses?
Note: We exclude issues that apply primarily to students who

 Confidently enroll in and successfully complete first undergraduate math course or a widely acceptable alternative on schedule.
 Confidently decide they do not need to complete first undergraduate math course or a widely acceptable alternative. [And who do not regret this decision some years later.]
“Gateway courses — college credit–bearing and/or developmental education…. As long as there have been U.S. colleges and universities, there have been entry courses that pose difficulties for students — courses that have served more as weedingout rather than gearingup experiences for undergraduates. Perhaps the gatewaycourse weedout function was more appropriate in the days when a college or university credential was reserved for a privileged few, or even during the era when a high school credential was more than adequate preparation for work and life in a democratic republic. But we no longer live in those times.”
Excerpt from “Improving Teaching, Learning, Equity, and Success in Gateway Courses” by Andrew K. Koch (Editor); New Directions for Higher Education, Number 180 (JB HE Single Issue Higher Education) 1st Edition DOI: 10.1002/he
https://www.jngi.org/blog/2018/1/3/improvingteachinglearningequityandsuccessingatewaycourses1?rq=developmental
Specific example: “Math 101” and Beginning, Developmental, Remedial [College] Math
Basic Algebra and/or Algebra I and/or College Algebra, … Not Algebra II, Statistics, Calculus
“Completion of Mathematics Remediation is the Single Largest Barrier to College Completion”
“Students Assessed as Needing Developmental (Remedial) Algebra Are More Likely to Graduate If They Take CollegeLevel Statistics Instead,” Alexandra W. Logue, CASE, Graduate Center, CUNY; Mari WatanabeRose, CUNY Central Office of Academic Affairs; Slide from presentation 2017 ASHE Conference, Houston, Texas, November 9, 2017
https://www2.calstate.edu/csusystem/whythecsumatters/graduationinitiative2025/academicpreparation/Documents/ashe110717.pdf
“One of the most striking findings is that all seven guides emphasized this point, in particular: The status quo is unacceptable.” [Page 1]
” A Common Vision for Undergraduate Mathematical Sciences Programs in 2025″
Karen Saxe, Macalester College; Linda Braddy, MAA; Published and Distributed by
The Mathematical Association of America; Copyright ©2015 The Mathematical Association of America, Inc.; ISBN 9780883858400
“1 Introduction [Page 3]
Freshman and sophomore mathematics and statistics courses function as gateways to many majors, and they are crucial for preparing mathematically and scientificallyliterate citizens. Yet:
• Each year only about 50 percent of students earn a grade of A, B, or C in college algebra
(Ganter & Haver, 2011).
• Women are almost twice as likely as men to choose not to continue beyond Calculus I,
even when Calculus II is a requirement for their intended major (Bressoud, 2011).
• In 2012, 19.9 percent of all bachelor’s degrees were awarded to underrepresented minority students (9.5 percent to Blacks, 9.8 percent to Hispanics). However, only 11.6
percent of mathematics bachelor’s degrees were awarded to underrepresented minority students (4.9 percent to Blacks, 6.4 percent to Hispanics) ( www.nsf.gov/statistics/nsf07308/content.cfm?pub_id=3633&id=2).
• Failure rates under traditional lecture are 55 percent higher than the rates observed under more active approaches to instruction (Freeman et al., 2014).”
I. Recap and Discuss Previously Shared Articles [Excerpts below on this page]
II. Discuss New Resources & Prompts
(Suggested after May 10)
A. Does this excerpted list of “features” include the elements of Adaptive Courseware most important to you?
“Find courseware to meet your teaching and learning needs” in website “Find the right Edtech products… Use our search tools to explore products that support your learners….Search Courseware Products…Student Success Products” From EdSurge
Brief descriptions and links to approximately 60 “courseware products” organized by “REFINE BY FEATURE” and “YOUR REQUIREMENTS. Site welcomes suggestions for additional items.
 ADAPTIVITY
The content can be adjusted in relation to a learner’s knowledge
 CUSTOMIZATION
Educators and course designers can alter learning or assessment content
 LEARNER AUTONOMY
Learners can impact or augment instruction based on their choices
 SOCIALEMOTIONAL
Use of feedback and interventions based on a learner’s socialemotional state
 ASSESSMENT
Academic structures and the capacity to assess learning in relation to them
 COLLABORATION
Ability for learners and/or educators to engage with each other in the context of learning
B. “Getting students to do the work”
Thoughtful comment from Doug Eder:
“As a ‘lumper’ more than a ‘splitter,’ I see various teaching interventions — programmed texts, adaptive software, technologyassisted teaching, flipped classrooms, and so on — merely as ways to get students to do the work. IMHO, there is no magic pedagogy, electronic or otherwise, to do this. I have learned from programmed texts and I have taught from programmed texts. I have also lectured, used Barbara Walvoord’s inclass homework long before the ‘flipped classroom’ became an item, and eventually adopted problembased learning when Howard Barrows came from McMaster University to the SIU School of Medicine. I found that none of this matters a whit except for when students themselves study. In this, I concur with one of Tom Angelo’s workshop titles: ‘Doing Assessment as if Learning Matters Most.’
“In short, what professors do matters. What students do matters more.
“I’m looking forward to hearing what others think about all this on Friday. —Doug”
— Email from Doug Eder to Steve Gilbert May 22, 2019; forwarded with his permission.
III. Discussion: Examples and Factors
What might support or impede the effective integration of adaptive courseware into “Killer” Gateway Courses such as Math, English, Chem 101.
 You are welcome to ask questions and to offer your own opinions, especially those based on your past experience and current activities at institutions you know.
IV. Discussion: Claims, Hopes, Disappointments
2:45pmET Closing
REFLECT SILENTLY (MAKE NOTES IF YOU LIKE) SHARE VIA CHAT
 What was most useful today?
 What was not clear enough?
 What would be a useful followup?
Requests and Recommendations?
 How might you contribute to the followup?
Next Week: THEME: ….
Identify Specific Activity, Date, People
———————————————–
“Although Skinners [Skinner’s] initial programmed instruction format has undergone many transformations, most adaptations retain three essential features:
(1) an ordered sequence of items, either questions or statements to which the student is asked to respond;
(2) the student’s response, which may be in the form of filling in a blank, recalling the answer to a question, selecting from among a series of answers, or solving a problem; and
(3) provision for immediate response confirmation, somtimes [sometimes] within the program frame itself but usually in a different location, as on the next page in a programmed textbook or in a separate window in the teaching machine. (Joyce, Weil & Calhoun, 2000:332)”
Subtopic headings from article (selected excerpts available further below):
 Definitions
 Theory and history
 The architectures of programmed instruction
 Additional topics
4.1 The role of the teachers in Skinner’s thoughts
4.2 Technological progress
4.3 Opencontents and programmed instructional texts
See open educational resources.
 References and links
by David Raths, Education Trends, Campus Technology, 04/24/19,
“…use of adaptive courseware in the humanities.
” U. of Miss. …using adaptive learning to help firstyear writing students grasp rhetorical concepts…used ..locally contextualized personalized learning courseware to address the readiness gap…in firstyear composition,
“…working with adaptive learning is not intuitive to composition instructors.
“Collaborating for Student Success
“…effort to scale up the use of adaptive courseware to increase student retention and graduation rates. The eight universities have been guided by the APLU’s Personalized Learning Consortium and funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. (In January 2017, Campus Technology interviewed university leaders involved about ramping up these efforts; see “Scaling Up with Adaptive Learning.”)
“Oregon State U. APLU project …college algebra, …the most commonly failed course in the country. ‘Our DFW [grades of D, F or withdrawals] rates have gone down significantly since we started, so we know that at least for the course we are using it in it is working.’ …uses a McGraw Hill courseware product called ALEKS…. ‘we started with it as our math placement test,…then ALEKS has learning modules they [students] can work on to improve their placement…students…were performing well in the courses they were placing into’,…
“Choosing the Right Courseware
“…some platforms created by publishers have proprietary content, while other digital learning platforms are contentagnostic, and faculty members can use open educational resources or their own content with them.
“…it might make sense to choose the courseware first and then the textbook.
“One of the biggest complaints from students about digital learning platforms, O’Sullivan added, is that the courseware may be attached to a textbook, but the professor is not using it. …It is best when everything aligns exactly and students are applying what they are learning in the courseware directly in class.’
“Adaptive Learning in the Humanities
“‘I would have thought before getting involved in adaptive learning that English composition might not apply, but they have applied it beautifully and I see other applications in the humanities where people are using it. I know the inclination is for STEM to use adaptive courseware, but I can’t think of a discipline that [it wouldn’t be useful for].’
“‘Students who are less prepared use them [“micro modules”] as a way to learn this content and strategies. Students who are well prepared use them as a way to refresh their understanding. If the courseware tells us they understand the strategy, but it is not showing up in their papers, as instructors we try to figure out how we can help them apply that. The courseware allows us to assess whether they have a basic understanding of the concepts, even if they can’t apply it in their papers.’
“Asked about how adaptive learning could be applied to other humanities courses, Forgette suggested that patience is going to be key. ‘Before we figured out how this could work with composition, we had a lot of failed projects…We had to step back and look at how we could use this locally and how it could benefit our students. That is when we got a project that we felt was successful.’…adaptive courseware can free up instructors to spend time on what they see as most valuable.”
———————————————
EXCERPT from news release Monday, May 6, 2019:
“John Wiley & Sons… to acquire the assets of Knewton, a provider of affordable courseware and adaptive learning technology“
“…knewton… has developed an advanced learning system demonstrated to deliver highlypersonalized learning experiences that drive superior outcomes. The Company’s Alta courseware platform delivers highquality, Open Educational Resource (OER) content to more than 300 colleges and universities, with course offerings in key subject areas, including math, chemistry and economics.”
“Wiley Signs Agreement to Purchase the Assets of Knewton,” Monday, May 6, 2019 8:00 am EDT, https://newsroom.wiley.com/pressrelease/allcorporatenews/wileysignsagreementpurchaseassetsknewton
